CAB 2019 | Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2019 | Assam Protests

CAB 2019 | Citizenship Amendment Bill, 2019 | Assam Protests


Hey every body this is Priya and you are watching Finology Legal In today’s video we will get know about the Citizenship Amendment Bill what kind of problem this bill is going to solve ? What changes will it bring? And very important that what problems people are having with this bill? All these we will get know about in today’s video And to know about this topic very well, we should know the meaning of these two important terms First is “Persecution” which simple meaning is to misbehave or doing violence or discriminating If one group is doing violence or discriminating on the other group it is called Persecution Persecution could be of many types such as religious persecution, Political persecution, and being rascit The second important term of this topic is “Immigrant” If any person leaves his country and starts living in other country permanently then he is an immigrant for that nation Next we will understand the relationship of India with the neighbour countries. Which is very interesting to know So this is India and its Neighbour countries Between 12th to 20th Century, due to religious persecution in Iran The Parsis of Iran migrated at a large scale towards India In 1947 partition happened between India and Pakistan due to which more than 1 crore people migrated to each other country And because of this Partition, The Bangladesh Freedom Movement between 1960-71 lakhs of bangladeshi people migrated to India because of this war for freedom After that in 1959-60 due China – Tibet war Tibet many Tibetians migrated to India And due to Soviet – Afghan war and religious persecution over there Afghans also migrated to India Like this only in between 1980-2000 due to Sri Lanka Civil War, Sri Lankan Tamils came here And during 2015-17, The Rohingyas of Myanmar migrated to India According to the sensus report of 2001 a huge amount of migrants in India are from Banladesh and pakistan The issue of Citizenship in India is discussed in two places- in Constituion of India and Citizenship of India Act, 1955 Constitution says that who will be the proper Indian Citizens in 1950, So the provision of the Constitution was helpful for our grand parents and fore fathers But the provisions after 1950 like who will called as Indian Citizen after 1950 How today any can be Indian Citizen or in coming days how any will able to acquire Indian citizenship? All these things are discussed in Indian Citizenship Act 1955 Now let us see what is the main purpose of this Bill This bill wants to change the way of acquring citizenship according to the act so how ? Firstly by changing the definition of illegal immigrant Till now the Illegal immigrant defined in this Act as If any person who comes to India for living without having valid passport or having fraud documents Or he has exceeded the permission limit of staying in India In that case that person will be called as illegal immigrant and he will be forced to leave the country But this bill changes the whole definition of this act And it says that before 31st December 2014 any people who has came to India by any ways and if they are from Afghanistan, Pakistan and Bangladesh and they belong to these 6 communities- Hindus, Sikhs,Buddhists,Jains, Parsis, Christians So now these peoples will not called as illegal immigrants So according to the act people who were called as illegal immigrants, bill amends that thing and all these people who came from these 3 countries will not be an illegal immigrant Second big change is coming in process of Acquiring citizenship Before it was like, if you are coming from Pakistan and willing to take Indian Citizenship So for that you have to spend 11 years in India or have to do any government service and after that you will get Indian Citizenship And this bill changes this whole proecess and it says that, If you are from these 3 countries and you belong to these 6 communities from these countries then you have to spend only 5 years instead of 11 to get Indian citizenship so according to this the date has been given since 2014 from December 2014 to 2019 its 5 years and all these illegal immigrants will convert in to Indian Citizens So the first major problem coming across this bill is that Why the government has chosen only these 3 countries and why only 6 communities from these countries and why you excluded other neighbour countries and other communites? and it is a violation of Article 14 And for the answer the answer of this question I have listened to the parliamentary discussions and a saw Harish Salve on a channel answering the questions regarding this bill He said that the main moto of this bill is to expand the loss of migration and to relax it So now how much it should be expanded and relaxed, its a policy matter Amit Shah told that in our neighbouring countries minority communities are being tortured and they are affected by religious persecution. So why we choosed only these 3 countries? Because the constitution structure of these 3 countries declares it as a Islamic State not as a secular country And in these countries these 6 communities are minorities and are going through religious persecution that’s why we selected these 3 countries and the 6 communities The second most and big opposition is coming from the north eastern states of India Specifically from Assam, and this opposition also has a deep rooted history, let us know that from 1920’s when riots began to happen all over in India, Since then only from east Bengal people started migrating to north eastern states specifically in Assam So its usual that the people who were migrated there were started holding lands over there So slowly what happened that the population of refugees started increasing as compare to the locals over there After that from 1948 India- Pakistan to 1971 Bangladesh formation lakhs of people migrated to the North east state after the independence during the time of State re organisation The cities of north east were worried about ethnicity related to the culture and language That’s why North east states was given special status same as Jammu and Kashmir like 6th schedule, In a line permit and many like this Now in 1978 what happened that Assam’s MP Heera Lal Patwari dies and because of this re election has to be done Then the matter which to existence that suddenly the majority of registered voters in Assam increases Means the majority of refugees increased a lot, and Elections was cancelled with the immediate effect and Student leaders started protesting saying that this Illegal influx should be stopped and all the illegal immigrants should be detained and deported This protest is known as Assam Andolan which was from 1979 to 1985 And the result of that protest was Assam Accord which came in 1985 Assam Accord says that if you belong to any religion and if you have migrated to Assam after 24th march 1971 then you will not be called as a citizen you will be an illegal immigrant and to fulfill the objective of Assam Accord government introduced NRC “National Register of Citizens” in which 19 Lakh illegal immigrants were noticed But now since the CAB has came it says that it should be considered from 2014 instead of 1971 before December 2014 people who migrated to India from these 3 countries and from those 6 communities will not be called as Illegal immigrants and will be called as citizens So this was Citizenship Ammendment Bill Which problem it is trying to solve and what problems are people having with this bill I hope you like this video and you have understood about this But do let me know in the comment box that what you think will majority people get benefited by this bill? And for benefiting the majority, is it right to do this with minorities, do let me know That’s it for now see you in the next class. Bye Bye

Comments

  1. Post
    Author
    SUNIL KUMAR

    What is in the policy is yet to be seen in the coming days but the politics is very clear now. This is the deadly combination of NRC and CAA when the people shall be categorized into two groups, i.e. Muslims and Non-Muslims after introduction of NRC.

    Non-Muslims (who belong to the six religions) shall be able to get the benefits of the CAA whereas Muslims shall not be able to get the same because of the very conditions in the CAA.

    What will happen to those Muslims? Will they be deported anywhere else? How will the other Nation's Government accept them and first of all why?

    All these questions have only one answer that till the NRC-identified Muslims will not be extradited to other countries, they would be retained in the detention centers where they would live under lesser privileged section of India. They would not be able to exercise their own fundamental rights which they have now as Indian Citizens.

  2. Post
    Author
  3. Post
    Author
    MOHAMMAD ALI JINNAH

    If the purpose of the bill is persecution, why has the government assumed the persecution won’t take place after 2012. Why only these three countries, what about other neighbouring countries. Why lover the naturalisation period from 11 to 5 years. And finally, when the government is not able to provide jobs and services to the existing citizens, why then increase the burden by giving out citizenship.

  4. Post
    Author
    Salman pasha

    When NRC will introduce in whole India as Amit shah said , excluded people who are the actual citizen of india but don't have 50 years old papers or proof get citizenship by CAA except muslims ,what about that , is this not discrimination?
    Thay will stand the country in lines like demonitization.

  5. Post
    Author
    Laksh cravings

    Very brief detail about this act thanks but modi govt played gently by this act including 6 community except Muslim because of which Muslim came in India after 31 December 2014 they will be deport.. 🤘🤘

  6. Post
    Author
  7. Post
    Author
  8. Post
    Author
  9. Post
    Author
    Nayab Rasool

    Non muslims in Pakistan are safe and secured only they are doing just spreading propaganda, I know very well. I have so many friends of Pakistan, they told me and even Sikhs are also fully safe and secured there.just this fellows wat to convert and after that do torcher.

  10. Post
    Author
  11. Post
    Author
  12. Post
    Author
    Amit kumar sudarshan news fans

    सभी का खून शामिल था इस मिट्टी में अरे हम अनजान थोड़ी हैं जिनके अब्बा धर्म के नाम पर पाकिस्तान बांग्लादेश ले चुके हैं अब उनका भारत थोड़ी है जिहादी जहां-जहां बढ़ती है इनकी संख्या वहां अन्य किसी को जीने नहीं देते हैं कश्मीर का एक बड़ा उदाहरण है

  13. Post
    Author
  14. Post
    Author
  15. Post
    Author
    Harshit Upadhyaya

    i have seen your previous video in which you have explained complex topics really well but in this video i think you have delivered only the half knowledge

  16. Post
    Author
  17. Post
    Author
  18. Post
    Author
  19. Post
    Author
    sumit mishra

    This girl is wrong.. Illegal immigrant is not one who is belonging to non muslim category.. Rather it is about the minorities of those three countries.. Also non Muslims who can't prove that they are in India because of religious persecution then they won't be given citizenship

  20. Post
    Author
  21. Post
    Author
    Nisha Shukla

    Not Expected From You, This Map Is Fuckng wrong. Priya Madam Replace This map from Video As Soon As Possible.
    Gonna Report This Video.
    Every Do Report It.

  22. Post
    Author
    learning

    THIS VIDEO was AWESOME! It completely properly explained the bill and scenario for which it is made, current problems, agitation and misconception are not properly addressed, that's my personal view, otherwise awesome one!THANKS ma;am.

  23. Post
    Author
  24. Post
    Author
  25. Post
    Author
  26. Post
    Author
  27. Post
    Author
  28. Post
    Author
  29. Post
    Author
  30. Post
    Author
  31. Post
    Author
  32. Post
    Author
  33. Post
    Author
  34. Post
    Author
  35. Post
    Author
  36. Post
    Author
  37. Post
    Author
  38. Post
    Author
  39. Post
    Author
  40. Post
    Author
  41. Post
    Author
  42. Post
    Author
    Noor Hossain Khan

    ❌NRC❌
    ❌CAB❌
    A Kanoon Lagu Nahin Hona chahie Sarkar ko is Se Wapas Lena hoga India ke sanvidhan ke khilaf hai Musalman Ne Hindustan ke liye Jitna Khoon Bhaya Hai Itihaas gavah hai…

  43. Post
    Author
  44. Post
    Author
    Saumyaranjan Sahoo

    I was not aware of such details…while the whole country debates on NRC and CAA. I hope most of Indians don't know the same as well. Thank u for making such informative videos.👍

  45. Post
    Author
    Tai Gumja Tamin

    You didn't discuss "Chakma and Hajong or Tibetan issue " of Arunachal Pradesh….. without full knowledge don't discuss any subjects….👎👎👎

  46. Post
    Author
    Suhail Akhtar

    From all the videos that I've seen on CAA 2019 so far, this video offers the most accurate and clear explanation by far without any propaganda or any left/right bias.

  47. Post
    Author
  48. Post
    Author
  49. Post
    Author
  50. Post
    Author
  51. Post
    Author
  52. Post
    Author
  53. Post
    Author
  54. Post
    Author
    YOUTUBE THAMIZHAN

    Please Teach in English also, important words kin Hindi not able to understand so please the citizenship potion in English. Request

  55. Post
    Author
    Satyam Raut

    Or yha bill pass ho jyga tho kahna kon dega unn log ko..hm log ko tho rozgar mil nhi raha in ko kon dega or .yha 6 relgan kyu Muslim kyu nahi wha re bjp.. I m a student to preparing for upsc….

  56. Post
    Author
  57. Post
    Author
  58. Post
    Author
    Nana Raza

    Instead of making harmony govt is making it controversial. The article can easily be ammended stating that any immigrant from the respective countries will get the autonomous citizenship . Somehow the polarization intensions can be seen. The act by the way itself is beneficiary for immigrants the removal of religious factor can make it more perfect. Good Explanation thanks

  59. Post
    Author
    irish jammy

    In north east when 12,00,000 Bangladeshi Hindus were founded illegal immigrants this government is NRC they bought CAA. And said Bangladeshi Hindus can get citizenship without any documents. And Indian Muslims who r poor and without documents will be treated as illegal residents of India., what a Hippocrates. We are ousting our citizens and allowing Bangladeshi and Pakistani in our country. What a policy of government shame shame

  60. Post
    Author
    Author Axe

    We oppose CAB in North-east. Be it Hindus, Muslims or Christians immigrant you can't just dump them in North- East India for political gain. Are there no lands for the immigrants in North India ??

  61. Post
    Author
    Sandeep Gavara

    One amendment in your video, please explain about refugees and as you explained all illegal immigrants definition will change is not correct, this bill is mainly for refugees who undergone religious persecution.there is a lot of difference between refugees and immigrants

  62. Post
    Author
    Anish Rajput

    Hii..you mention two thing that is really confusing to me..
    1. All six minority immigrants will be eligible for indian citizenship , no matter how they inter in india (legally or illegally) , is it true or they must inter through legal process.
    2. Are they eligible to get citizenship in any north east state??

  63. Post
    Author
  64. Post
    Author
  65. Post
    Author
    ਜਗਪ੍ਰੀਤ SinGh

    flood ki vjah se (muslim)jiske ghr hi nhi bche vo kaise sabit krenge ki unke ancestor indians the…nd asam me kya frk pdta hai pehle bngladeshi muslim reh rhe the ab bngladeshi hindu rhenge vo bhi citizenship k sath…prblm to yeh hai asamese khud minorities bn jayenge

  66. Post
    Author
    Prabira kumar Panda

    Mam you are. Unique. Always. You. Have clearly mention that what is CAB. No doubt. It will. Benefit. For my country

  67. Post
    Author
  68. Post
    Author
    balhara family

    Our Country Govt. have should little rude against them should depot them bec. of the reason we have limited resources ,and they are creating only liabilities our over country nothing else then this India already suffer from many bad situation so it is creating water fall situation in make a developed country .
    Give me your opinion on my view…
    bec. I also want to know what you think on my opinion

  69. Post
    Author
    Mapaokhol Youtube

    There is nothing Humanity and nothing about religious persecution. It's all about Vote Bank. CAB par Plebiscite Karo let's us see.
    Hum to BJP ko nahin mante Magar illegal migrants to ushe God dikhega. The lotus will never bloom again.

  70. Post
    Author
  71. Post
    Author
    Saloni Sharma

    As India is diverse and a developing country… Thiz amendment is good for those who are being sufferd from thiz three countries but it is tough to accept other citizens…suddenly thiz decision..also India may suffer angreness wid d other countries which are excluded from thiz amendment.

  72. Post
    Author
  73. Post
    Author
    khizer ali

    Modi should provide employment Indian citizens, who have been leaving In India since centuries first then think about Pakistani, aghanis and Bangladeshi

  74. Post
    Author
  75. Post
    Author
  76. Post
    Author
    Hasib Hassan

    Clearly they are trying to make Muslim as second class Indian citizens or trying to kick them out of India & trying to put burden to Bangladesh, also modi is deadly against Muslim & he also killed 20000 Muslim in ghugrat rite , he is a killer

  77. Post
    Author
  78. Post
    Author
  79. Post
    Author
  80. Post
    Author
  81. Post
    Author
  82. Post
    Author
  83. Post
    Author
  84. Post
    Author
  85. Post
    Author
  86. Post
    Author
  87. Post
    Author
    umarshahroz md

    Tell me
    They r illegal… If someone is from China,nepal or other countries except those 3…but he says that he belongs to those 3 then acc to Amit Shah, they will all get citizenship bcoz they will not be asked of any document… As Amit Shah said… Koi documents ki zarurat nahi..
    Then how will we know that they r from those 3 countries

  88. Post
    Author
  89. Post
    Author
    Md. Abu Naim Sardar

    There is a big wrong mistake. That is Bangladesh is not a Islamic State. It’s secular. Not to rise a wrong information

  90. Post
    Author
  91. Post
    Author
  92. Post
    Author
  93. Post
    Author
  94. Post
    Author
    Meenakshi Chandel

    Thanks alot dear the way you teach is best. It's very easy to understand. Your videos helped me in my LLB exams . Keep up the good work . Love and blessings to u.

  95. Post
    Author
  96. Post
    Author
  97. Post
    Author
  98. Post
    Author
  99. Post
    Author
    Imran Khan

    Miss finology… Can u shed light on dangers of NRC+CAA? On national level!!!
    We don't have any problems with CAA… The danger is when it's merged with NRC.

  100. Post
    Author
    Adil zaman

    Ap nai ye nahi batya k new bill ju 2019 me aya hae os nai 2014 se logo ko legal karar de deya gaya hae par waha pe ju Assam acord ta wu tu 1971 k bad oppose karta hae citizenship ko. Tu es darmayan wale period me NCR ata hae tu wu keya kehta hae or kya assam accord ko oppose karta hae mtlb 1971 se till to 2014 tak k logo ko india me citicizenship mil jata hae k nahi?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *