‘The Five’ reacts to Trump looking to end birthright citizenship

‘The Five’ reacts to Trump looking to end birthright citizenship


THIS IS “THE FIVE” .” IT’S A BATTLE OF BIG IDEAS, PRESIDENT TRUMP IN 2020 DEMOCRATS CLASHING ON KEY ISSUE ISSUES. THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION SAYS IT’S TAKING A BIG STEP TOWARDS ENDING CATCH AND RELEASE BY SCRAPPING THE FLORES AGREEMENT WHICH LIMITS THE AMOUNT OF TIME MIGRANT FAMILIES CAN BE DETAINED. TRUMP SAYING HE COULD END BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP. WATCH THIS.>>WE ARE LOOKING AT THAT VERY SERIOUSLY. YOU HAVE A BABY ON OUR LANDS, THE BABY IS NOW U.S. CITIZEN. WE’RE LOOKING AT IT VERY, VERY SERIOUSLY. FRANKLY IT’S RIDICULOUS.>>Jesse: 2020 DEMOCRATS ARE SHORT ON ACTUAL SOLUTIONS BUT HAVE PLENTY OF INSULTS FOR PRESIDENT TRUMP. THEY ARE GETTING AN ASSIST FROM THE MEDIA. CHECK IT OUT.>>THIS PRESIDENT IS ABSOLUTELY DETERMINED TO CARRY OUT MAXIMUM CRUELTY ON LITTLE CHILDREN WHO ARE BROWN.>>THEY WOULD RIP KIDS FROM THE BOSOMS OF THEIR MOTHERS.>>IT’S A RIDICULOUS NOTION TO OVERTURN THE 14TH AMENDMENT. IT’S A RACIST ON ITS FACE. HE IS TRYING TO DRIVE US APART, MAKE US ANGRY.>>IMMIGRANT FAMILIES AND KIDS WILL BE HELD INDEFINITELY AT THE PLEASURE OF THE TRUMP ADMINISTRATION. KIND OF LIKE GUANTANAMO.>>EVERYTHING ABOUT IMMIGRATION HE HAS DONE TO SCARE PEOPLE.>>Jesse: IS IT LITERALLY LIKE GUANTANAMO, JUDGE? THOSE BABIES, SO LUCKY TO BE AMERICAN.>>Judge Jeanine: A QUARTER OF A MILLION BABIES ARE BORN IN THE UNITED STATES WHO ARE SO-CALLED ANCHOR BABIES. THE COST OF THIS COUNTRY’S TWO AND A QUARTER BILLION DOLLARS TO THE WORLD’S GROSS — TO THE HOSPITALS. THE 14TH AMENDMENT MAKES IT VERY CLEAR THAT YOU ARE A CITIZEN IF YOU ARE SOMEONE WHO’S IN THE UNITED STATES AND SUBJECT TO THE JURISDICTION THEREOF. THE KEY CASE — IS THAT HAIR SPRAY?>>Juan: YOU KNOW I LOVE YOU, JUDGE. I’M HELPING YOU OUT.>>Judge Jeanine: THE KEY CASE INVOLVED AN INDIVIDUAL WHOSE PARENTS WERE CHINESE AND HE WAS BORN IN THE UNITED STATES WHILE THEY WERE HERE AND THEY WOULDN’T LET HIM BACK AND WHEN HE LEFT THE COUNTRY. THE SUPREME COURT SAID LOOK, HERE’S THE BOTTOM LINE. HIS PARENTS HAVE A LEGAL RIGHT TO BE HERE AND THEREFORE WERE GOING TO LET HIM BE A CITIZEN. THEY HAVE NEVER ACTUALLY ANSWERED THE QUESTION WHICH IS ON EVERYONE’S MINDS RIGHT NOW AND THAT IS CAN YOU BECOME A CITIZEN IF YOUR MOTHER IS NINE MONTHS PREGNANT, JUMPS OVER THE WALL AND GIVES BIRTH?>>Jesse: JUAN, THE AUTHOR OF THE 14TH AMENDMENT SAID IT WAS PRIMARILY DIRECTED AT SLAVES, NOT DISCUSSING ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS OR SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF AMBASSADORS FROM OTHER COUNTRIES.>>Juan: JUSTICE WATERS, I’M GUESSING YOU’RE HAVING AN ARGUMENT IF THE SUPREME COURT.>>Jesse: THOSE PEOPLE WERE LEGAL RESIDENTS.>>Juan: YOU KEEP TALKING AND HURTING YOURSELVES.>>Jesse: I FEEL FINE.>>Juan: REPUBLICANS SAYING THE PRESIDENT SHOULDN’T BE DISCUSSING THIS AND THAT THIS IS ESTABLISHED LAW. SUPREME COURT LAW. NOT LOWER COURTS, THE SUPREME COURT HAS SAID UNDER THE 14TH AMENDMENT, CHILD BORN IN THE UNITED STATES IS AN AMERICAN CITIZEN. NOT SUBJECT TO DEBATE. THE LARGER POINT HERE IS ABOUT IMMIGRATION. THE PRESIDENT CONTINUES TO GO AFTER AND TRY TO DEMONIZE IMMIGRANTS IN THIS COUNTRY AS A POLITICAL STIR FOR HIS BASE. I SAW HIS NUMBERS IN THE AP POLL, DOWN TO 36% APPROVAL. HE IS LOOKING FOR ANYTHING, ANYTHING THAT HE CAN TO FIND A WAY TO GIN UP SUPPORT. HE DOESN’T HAVE ANY IDEAS ON IMMIGRATION.>>Greg: THAT’S WHAT THIS IS ALL ABOUT!>>Juan: NO IDEAS.>>Greg: PORTABLY BEEN TALKING ABOUT FOR THREE YEARS? MY GOD. YOU HAVE BEEN TALKING FOR 5 MINUTES.>>Juan: HIS ONLY IDEA HAS BEEN BUILD A WALL AND HE HASN’T EVEN DONE THAT.>>Greg: HERE IS THE ISSUE THAT’S THE REAL PROBLEM, IT’S NOT JUST WITH IMMIGRATION. IT’S HOMELESSNESS AND OTHER PROBLEMS. THE LEFT ADHERES TO ONE SINGULAR STRATEGY AND THAT IS ANY KIND OF PROCESS, ANY KIND OF LAW, ANY KIND OF LOGIC OR ANY KIND OF REASON IS A SYMPTOM OF CRUELTY. YOU WILL BE ACCUSED OF DEMONIZING. IF YOU WANT TO HELP THE HOMELESS OFF THE STREET, YOU DEMONIZE. IF YOU WANT TO ENFORCE YOUR BORDER, YOU DEMONIZE. THIS ONLY HAPPENS WHEN THE OTHER SIDE IS IN CHARGE, RIGHT? THE REPUBLICANS IN CHARGE ONCE THE DEMOCRATS ARE IN CHARGE, THEY START ACTING LIKE ADULTS. PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OB PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OM PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OA PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OT PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OD PRESIDENT PRESIDENT OL PRESIDENT PRESIDENT ON ADULT AND HE WAS SAYING THE SAME THING PRESIDENT TRUMP THE SAME. A PROCESS, RULES AND ENFORCEMENT, ADULTS GET THIS. THE MEDIA AND THE DEMS, YOU CANNOT TELL THE DIFFERENCE. YOU COULDN’T TELL WHICH WAS IN THE MEDIA ON WHICH WAS RUNNING FOR PRESIDENT BECAUSE THEY ARE THE SAME ANIMAL. I MEAN ANIMAL PURELY AS A METAPHOR.>>Sandra: I FEEL LIKE I HAVE TO RAISE MY VOICE TO MAKE MY POINT.>>Greg: WELL, THIS IS “THE FIVE.”>>Sandra: ACTUAL WORDS, OBAMA REFERRED TO ACTING DHS SECRETARY, WE HAD ON “AMERICA’S NEWSROOM” .” A SIGNIFICANT STEP IN ADDRESSING THE CORE ASPECT OF THE CRISIS IN THE BORDER. OBAMA’S FORMER BORDER PATROL CHIEF, MARK MORGAN WAS ON THIS MORNING, SAID THIS IS A GAME CHANGER. THIS WILL ABSOLUTELY ELIMINATE AT LEAST PART OF THE BORDER CRISIS BUT YOU REWIND ONE YEAR AGO WHEN JEH JOHNSON, OBAMA’S DHS SECRETARY MADE THE POINT THAT FLORES IS AN ISSUE. IT’S A LOOPHOLE THAT HAS TO BE CLOSE. I WANT TO ADDRESS THE MEDIA, INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME, SUPREME COURT RULING, 2001, 180 DAYS IS THE LONGEST PERIOD OF TIME. THEY ARE TALKING ABOUT 50 TO 60 DAYS THAT THEY NEED TO PROPERLY PROCESS THE MIGRANTS.>>Juan: WHAT WE HAVE ON THE TABLE SHOULD BE HOW DO WE PROPERLY PROCESS AND DEAL WITH THE FACT THAT WE HAVE ON THE BOOKS ASYLUM LAWS AND WE WANT TO HOLD TO THE LAW. GREG TALKS ABOUT LET’S DO EVERYTHING BY THE BOOKS, BY THE

Comments

  1. Post
    Author
    Alex P

    This is tough. I agree but I also think that as an American I think that if my child is born here they should be considered Americans. I mean how about sending and setting up more border patrol agents along the border and offices. The walls almost done. Let’s do that first before we take the right of Americans.

  2. Post
    Author
  3. Post
    Author
    ricky brock

    children should be of the same citizenship as the mother ! pure and simple , The child belongs in the mother's care till the child is old enough to care for themselves . The Democrats are pure HATE nothing else !!!!!

  4. Post
    Author
    Michael Boone

    What is it to be American? Nothing. Thats the problem. We all only have America. These immigrants have their own lands. How is this so hard to understand for the children of migrants in congress.

  5. Post
    Author
    Joel Sattler

    Countries that give "birthright citizenship" to children  born in their country:
    Antigua and Barbuda
    Argentina
    Barbados
    Belize
    Bolivia
    Brazil
    Canada
    Chad
    Chile
    Costa Rica
    Cuba
    Dominica
    Ecuador
    El Salvador
    Fiji
    Grenada
    Guatemala
    Guyana
    Honduras
    Jamaica
    Lesotho
    Mexico
    Nicaragua
    Pakistan
    Panama
    Paraguay
    Peru
    Saint Kitts and Nevis
    Saint Lucia
    Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
    Trinidad and Tobago
    Tuvalu
    United States
    Uruguay
    Venezuela
    ===========

  6. Post
    Author
    Garrett

    I didn't actually think I'd see racist assholes in the comment section, because I usually assume people are better than this, but jeez you guys need to calm down.

  7. Post
    Author
    John Dunn

    send barron ("birth-right") and melonia (over-stay work visa) back to
    Ukraine. melania's parent's ("chain migration"), too. three examples
    (according to tRUMP) of immigrants that shouldn't be granted entry into
    America. i have to agree with him on these…

  8. Post
    Author
    John Dunn

    send barron ("birth-right") and melonia (over-stay work visa) back to
    Ukraine. melania's parent's ("chain migration"), too. three examples
    (according to tRUMP) of immigrants that shouldn't be granted entry into
    America. i have to agree with him on these…

  9. Post
    Author
    Sherlock Jones

    This is the most common sense approach to maintaining any hope of sovereignty.
    American sovereignty is meaningless without enforced laws that preserve it.
    Is Globalization a forgone conclusion?
    It already exists in the Silicon Valley.
    Homelessness is skyrocketing and new development caters to aliens. The land where I have lived my whole life is nolonger distinguishable as American and all but a fraction of citizens are being forced to the fringes of a new 3rd world.

  10. Post
    Author
  11. Post
    Author
    Kenneth Schauer

    For everyone that thinks breaking and entering is no longer illegal can we have your address and we can cross right in your back door!!!!!!! Thanks amego!!!

  12. Post
    Author
  13. Post
    Author
  14. Post
    Author
    Big AL

    The right wing claim to be Christian but really they are demons destroying this country by robbing the working poor and giving that to the already greedy rich!! They only talk it but they can never walk it! They go after abortion so they can claim to be for God but they hurt the poor that Christ himself said to help out! The republican party is the most evil and twisted party because they use religion to justify their evil deeds but they fail to see that the God they claim to believe in, is watching them all and they better hope they never face him on judgement day, because they will all get a huge rude awakening and what they deserve!!! It's time to call them all out for being the no good rotten fruit bearing fake Christian hypocrite lying racist sexist twisted evil bastards that they really are and in 2020, no more of them left in office, time to vote out every republican for good!!

  15. Post
    Author
  16. Post
    Author
  17. Post
    Author
    Musical Paradox

    oh, so now democrats care about "ripping children from the bosoms of their mothers"? I wish they had the same sympathy for unborn American children.

  18. Post
    Author
    Daily F

    If your born in the UNITED STATE by American father in mother then your American if you born from mexico you are a mexican child it a fact i support TRUMP.

  19. Post
    Author
  20. Post
    Author
    Stew L

    Frank A has information about the stabbing in Fullerton. J is aware that there was a tease at the dorm. Witch craff, seduction. US should mobilize vs black countries.

  21. Post
    Author
  22. Post
    Author
    Kyle Larson

    What 970 idiots object.this is our nation.go to Mexico and live there.this whining..racism..always kids..ripped from the bosum..what horseshit

  23. Post
    Author
    Suntouso

    Keep them out! The birth right is not right, because they are not anchored to our laws.
    Juan is a totally Arsehole, and should be sent back to Cuba 🇨🇺!

  24. Post
    Author
  25. Post
    Author
  26. Post
    Author
    Mike Matthews

    HAS BETO EVER HAD HIS I.Q. TESTED? OR BEEN CHECKED FOR TERRETS? WHEN HE SPEAKS ITS ALLWAYS IN BROKEN SENTENCES. LIKE HE HAS TICKS. IT DRIVES ME TO DISTRACTION. 😲

  27. Post
    Author
  28. Post
    Author
    The Rocker

    ,,,, lmao,,, why,,, lol,,, Why is, and how is, it possible of all things, I hear a rant about "immigrants in America" when Juan should have said "illegal immigrants"… We do remember,,, how about a hotter topic, talk about the Byrne 🙂

  29. Post
    Author
  30. Post
    Author
  31. Post
    Author
    Selistene Van Rooyen

    Shitist news agency ever, always spreading false news by twisting the truth and paying people to say things to enforce their crruption

  32. Post
    Author
    spot light

    Juan is basically, just a silly leftist crackpot and I resent that fool being the sole representative on the show of people of color. He's constantly OPEN BORDERS insanity and pretending that LEGAL and ILLEGAL immigration are the same. On the "anchor baby" matter, he intentionally misrepresents what the 14th amendment and the U.S. Supreme Court actually said. He's a LYING leftist crackpot, but his filthy misconduct DOES accurately represent the current level of deep, filthy corruption in the current Democratic Party!

  33. Post
    Author
    Margo Bradley

    This ludicrous policy should never have happened , other country’s would deport both or arrest them for spies, mass deportation is in order illegal is criminal

  34. Post
    Author
    Winter's King

    You wouldn't need to overturn the 14th amendment. It was written so that former slaves would gain citizenship, Not immigrants. And was enforced as such for decades only being changes by the Kennedys later on.

  35. Post
    Author
  36. Post
    Author
    Henry Wilson

    Juan the Affirmative Action hire reveals his own personal racism towards White People and disdain for America. He is the cleaned up Diet Coke version of Colin Kapernick

  37. Post
    Author
  38. Post
    Author
    David Ardis

    Where both parents are NOT citizens of the US a child born here should not be a US Citizen, There are Countries where a family has to be there 5 generations before a child can be born a citizen.

  39. Post
    Author
  40. Post
    Author
  41. Post
    Author
  42. Post
    Author
  43. Post
    Author
  44. Post
    Author
  45. Post
    Author
    David Brown

    Pregnant alien women should be denied access to the USA. If an alien child is born in USA, it should automatically be NOT a citizen of of the USA.

  46. Post
    Author
    geishasecrets

    Juan is by far is the most educated, logical and reasonable amongst these talking clowns. And one of them is a judge, shame.

  47. Post
    Author
    Malcolm Mills

    Don't mention the Trillion dollar increase in budget deficit, the billions of dollars increase in trade deficit, American consumers having to pay the import tax I.e. Tariffs, don't mention any of Trump's complete lies and con tricks or his fraudulent university having to pay $20 million in reparation or Trump's fraudulent charity being run as a family bank account, or most of his products being made in China and Philippines or how much his resorts have charged taxpayers for his visits. Just keep up the BS.

  48. Post
    Author
  49. Post
    Author
    Margo Bradley

    Illegal is criminal , Cuba did this same exact thing , emptied their prisons and asylums and sent them all to the US, our policies wouldn’t allow them to be turned away and the United States got stuck with the best of the worst , where do you think the Castro brothers came from?

  50. Post
    Author
  51. Post
    Author
  52. Post
    Author
  53. Post
    Author
  54. Post
    Author
  55. Post
    Author
  56. Post
    Author
  57. Post
    Author
    Elaine Kilgore

    Mr. Williams, we would all appreciate if you would use the correct words when you’re describing your position. Trump is not against immigration. We are not against immigration. We are against illegal immigration. Would you please use the right terms, it might help your perspective.

  58. Post
    Author
    Searth Ngeam

    Juan, I'm an immigrant and I don't feel like the President is coming after us. If you're on a visa or an illegal immigrant, your children should not be a citizen. If you are an immigrant, you should be naturalized before your children can become a citizen. Citizen parents equal citizen children. It's common sense.

  59. Post
    Author
    John Doe

    JUAN wants to make me puke. He has to be the dumbest person I've ever seen. Thank God I don't live in Juan's world.

  60. Post
    Author
    katterkat58

    How many Countries let your baby become a citizen of their Country when the parents aren't? NONE Only America. It was only for those who Immigrated and Slaves during the 1700's when the Constitution was first signed. PERIOD

  61. Post
    Author
    Daniel Gray

    If you aren't a citizen and have a kid here, your kid shouldn't get citizenship. Also holding criminals in jail? You bastards!

  62. Post
    Author
    Cheryl Doss

    Some people study loopholes in a system only so they can slip through them and without any regard for what’s right or wrong. They lack character and conscience. They’re selfish, greedy and predatorial.

  63. Post
    Author
  64. Post
    Author
  65. Post
    Author
  66. Post
    Author
  67. Post
    Author
  68. Post
    Author
  69. Post
    Author
    Non ya

    Two (2) illegal aliens do not make a citizen. Birthright citizenship for illegal aliens is a common misconception. The plain meaning of the 14th Amendment means that one must BOTH be born in United States AND be subject to the jurisdiction thereof. Since there are two explicit requirements, they both cannot be met by simply being born on U.S. soil. The history of the drafting of the 14th Amendment makes clear that the language “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” meant a citizen could not owe allegiance to any other foreign power. This excludes illegal immigrants who are in defiance of U.S. jurisdiction and are citizens of a foreign power. Indians (Native Americans) such as myself were not even allowed to become citizens until 1924.

  70. Post
    Author
  71. Post
    Author
    James

    3:30. Is he doing that for his base? Or is your party just flip flopping on a bipartisan issue to call the President racist? Not so sure fam

  72. Post
    Author
  73. Post
    Author
    Looniper

    ".. it is not subject to debate"
    So is he advocating for the restoration of Slavery?
    Because Slavery was ruled a legal practice by the SCOTUS… and if their rulings are not subject to debate…..

    But he is wrong even to that. As they were saying, the SCOTUS did not determine that anyone born here becomes a citizen or is allowed to stay. They made the decision – On-Case – that someone born to LEGAL residents is.

    Legal Residents having a child here is as different to illegal aliens having one as is being a citizen vs not.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *